“What If Being Right Is Holding You Back?”

"When you sense your defensiveness rising, pause. That’s the moment when effectiveness begins, if you allow it."

What if the biggest barrier to your leadership growth isn’t being wrong — it’s needing to be right?

Most leaders don’t set out to protect their egos. But somewhere between expectations, incentives, and image, “being right” starts to feel like part of the job description. We learn to equate rightness with credibility, confidence, and control. And once that belief takes root, it becomes hard to admit when our certainty gets in the way of our effectiveness.

The need to be right is often perfection in disguise—the same impulse I wrote about in Perfection vs. Excellence—where leaders chase flawlessness instead of progress and end up trading impact for image.

 

From Being Right To Getting It Right

Being right is about validation. Getting it right is about value.

When we focus on being right, we cling to decisions, defend weak assumptions, and resist new data. We argue to win rather than to understand. This behavior erodes trust: If I must be right, then you must be wrong.

When we pursue effectiveness, we remain curious, seek feedback early, and make adjustments quickly. The difference isn’t intelligence, it’s orientation. One protects identity, the other advances outcomes.

 

Three Patterns That Trap Us

  • Ego. Leaders often believe their authority relies on being right. So they double down instead of welcoming challenges. Ironically, this makes them seem smaller, not stronger.
  • Many systems reward visible certainty — the leader who speaks first and loudest. However, the best decisions often come from those willing to test and iterate.
  • Emotion. Feeling threatened or frustrated can easily overshadow values such as humility, openness, and curiosity. When emotions take control, learning stops.

Every time we defend our correctness, we narrow the space for insight. Every time we choose curiosity, that space expands.

Real-World Examples

An early-stage founder admits, “I don’t know yet,” to the team and runs a weeklong experiment instead of spending a month debating the plan.

A Chief Product Officer asks the most skeptical person in the room to open the next review.

A Division President reverses course after customer data contradicts a flagship initiative and earns more trust, not less.

In each case, the leader chose the effectiveness of doing it right over the comfort of being right.

 

Three Contrasts To Remember

  1. Ego Are you protecting reputation or advancing results?
  2. Feelings Are you acting from emotion or from what you stand for?
  3. Being Right Getting It Right. Are you winning arguments or improving outcomes?

 

Your Next Move

Pick one live situation this week where you feel the pull to be right. Then:

  • Ask clarifying questions instead of defending your position.
  • Encourage a dissenting voice in the discussion.
  • State a hypothesis, not a conclusion, and run the simplest test that could prove you wrong.

When you sense your defensiveness rising, pause. That’s the moment when effectiveness begins, if you allow it.

 

A Closing Thought

People rarely remember who was right in the meeting. They recall who made them feel recognized and helped move things forward.

So what if the real sign of leadership isn’t being right, but being willing to get it right?

Let’s unlock better—together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *